Home » Time Capsule » Currently Reading:

Time Capsule: My Low-Tech Dentist Turns Out To Be a Closeted Techie: Why Nobody Cares What IT You Use, Only What Outcomes You Deliver

May 31, 2013 Time Capsule 1 Comment

I wrote weekly editorials for a boutique industry newsletter for several years, anxious for both audience and income. I learned a lot about coming up with ideas for the weekly grind, trying to be simultaneously opinionated and entertaining in a few hundred words, and not sleeping much because I was working all the time. They’re fun to read as a look back at what was important then (and often still important now).

I wrote this piece in December 2008.

My Low-Tech Dentist Turns Out To Be a Closeted Techie: Why Nobody Cares What IT You Use, Only What Outcomes You Deliver
By Mr. HIStalk


My 2005 experience with an IT-savvy dentist was not good. My first (and last) visit to Dr. High-Tech took forever since he had to show me his PACS equipment, his electronic dental record, and his swing-arm TV monitor that would allow me to watch the Three Stooges while getting drilled and scraped.

Unfortunately, he was also a terrible dentist: slow, annoyingly educational, and prone to ill-concealed panic. Despite a flawless exam a year earlier, Dr. High-Tech somberly declared that my mouth was in imminent danger of total destruction, requiring a long list of heroic and expensive interventions that included $7,000 worth of work on one tooth alone.

I headed off for a second opinion, picking a dentist at random from the phone book (I’ll call him Dr. Low-Tech). His conclusion: I needed a filling and nothing more.

I’ve gone to Dr. Low-Tech for the three years since. His office has wood floors, real living room furniture, and no Judge Judy on the TV. He takes his time, talks my ear off, and sings loudly and off-key with the piped-in oldies station. He doesn’t need a dream team of ultra-specialist colleagues. He doesn’t hurt me, he’s never late, and he doesn’t overcharge.

Last visit, I saw something as shocking as Mommy kissing Santa Claus. I followed Dr. Low-Tech out from the treatment room and watched him pass through an unmarked door, getting a brief glance of a massive LCD monitor whiteboard showing every room’s occupant and status.

No wonder he can single-handedly juggle maybe 10-12 patients at a time, all in various stages of numbing, drilling, and swishing. He’s using online scheduling and resource management!

Suddenly everything became clear. I remembered that instead of getting appointment reminder calls, I’d been getting “click if you’re coming” e-mails. The hygienist always knew my history. The front office ladies could always give a perfect balance on my insurance.

Dr. Low-Tech was a closeted techie. He used IT, but didn’t want it to get in the way of taking care of his patients in a personal and caring way. That’s unlike Dr. High-Tech, who hoped patients would be impressed with his gadgets since that’s about all he had going for him.

Dr. Low-Tech has it right. Patients don’t need to know about IT any more than they needed to understand the old-school manila folder filing system. ‘Most Wired’ nonsense aside, nobody gets points for owning technology, whether it’s a doctor, a mechanic, or an accountant. Those professionals are free to use whatever tools they want, but they’ll be judged on outcomes, not on what they’re packing under the hood. Tools might make them a little bit better, but that’s about it.

Measuring the impact on the patient experience should be a part of every technology implementation review. Did patients notice? Was their impression of the overall experience (not the technology itself) better or worse? Did it enhance their experience, or did it get in the way and take away from the human interaction and caring that most people would agree is a vital part of a patient encounter? Did outcomes change?

Doctors always say “first, do no harm.” That’s as true of technology as anything else. Even bad golfers carry around the same expensive gear that Tiger Woods uses, hoping that owning it will make them better golfers. Unfortunately for them, scores don’t lie.

View/Print Text Only View/Print Text Only

HIStalk Featured Sponsors


Currently there is "1 comment" on this Article:

  1. I always find it fascinating when I circle back to some writings of my own from years gone-by and upon rereading, the core of the sentiment still applies today despite a few technological advances or changes in general that have transpired along the way. Doctor, this 2008 piece of yours speaks to me in the exact same way. We really don’t demand the bells and whistles nor even appreciate them really unless the initial task at hand has been handled right in the first place. Excellent choice for a re-post. Thx Doc!

Subscribe to Updates



Text Ads

Report News and Rumors

No title

Anonymous online form
Rumor line: 801.HIT.NEWS



Founding Sponsors


Platinum Sponsors

































































Gold Sponsors
















Reader Comments

  • Vaporware?: Which part is not factual? If I'm wrong, I'd be happy to stand corrected....
  • Martin Shkreli: This "article" is nonsense and brings down the quality of this website with unnecessary excitement regarding blockchains...
  • Craig Joseph, MD: I'm not struck by the infighting or backstabbing; that's par for the course at a complicated organization as you describ...
  • Another One: This comment by Vaporware is not factual....
  • Frank Poggio: This decision was a classic example of "The devil you know vs. the devil you don't..."...
  • Mr. HIStalk: The app used in the study was Medisafe. But I think the point is app-independent -- app use improved adherence a tiny bi...
  • Vaporware?: HIT, we need many many more people grinding this axe. If you really want me to regurgitate the laundry list of facts...
  • Mr. HIStalk: I should mention that I'm reading between the lines in assuming that, possibly incorrectly. The article says members sti...
  • John Yossarian: All the hullabaloo around UIC's Epic and Cerner mess is pretty pointless. And so are the Black Book and KLAS results. No...
  • Hold the Salt please: A study finds that app-issued medication reminders don’t help people with high blood pressure bring it down. Was t...

Sponsor Quick Links