Home » News » Currently Reading:

News 12/15/17

December 14, 2017 News 11 Comments

Top News


Cerner files a protest with the state of Illinois, claiming that it unfairly chose Epic for a $100 million project at UI Health, which uses both systems.


Cerner says its bid was lower and that it was not allowed to demonstrate its product during the selection. It also says that UI Health hired as its IT selection consultant Impact Advisors, which it says could benefit from an Epic selection, a charge Impact Advisors denies in saying it works with clients of all three UI Health bidders (Epic, Cerner, and Allscripts).

UI Health chose Epic in September 2017 with plans to replace systems from Cerner, Allscripts, and McKesson in a late 2019 go-live.

The health system responded to the protest by saying that it has experienced Cerner problems in the past; that Epic beat Cerner on RFP scoring; and Cerner wasn’t invited to do a demo because it failed a technical review.

UI Health says it twice tried to roll out Cerner ambulatory and failed both times due to system performance problems that it claims Cerner has admitted. It also notes that Cerner is ranked well below Epic by KLAS. Cerner pointed out that its academic medical center market share is significant and raises the question of how it failed the technical review, noting also that UI Health hasn’t upgraded its systems per Cerner’s recommendations.

Reader Comments


From Considerable Girth: “Re: White House EHR meeting. It’s interesting that as it was happening, the VA seemed to be digging deeper into Cerner’s interoperability capability as their planned contract signing data passed. Could it be that Cerner downplayed the idea of interoperability to make the case that the VA’s only hope of connecting to the DoD was to also buy Cerner? Rumor is that politicians and even some White House folks are puzzled at how Epic has connected to dozens of VA and DoD sites and 100 percent of Epic sites that are interested in sharing information.” Unverified. The VA, which planned to have its fast-tracked, no-bid Cerner contract signed by now, seems to be suddenly realizing that theoretical interoperability with the DoD and community-based providers isn’t necessarily a reality. That’s the kind of information that should have been fleshed out in performing due diligence, dictating strong contract terms, and convening stakeholders to define mutually agreeable goals, all of which seemed to have been skipped in the VA’s White House-pressured rush to sign a Cerner contract. Both the VA and DoD have awful track records in choosing, planning, and executing IT contracts and allowing cash-flush vendors and consulting firms to pull wool over their eyes, so somehow I don’t think everybody (especially veterans) lives happily ever after just because Cerner is running in both places. I have heard speculation from a couple of folks that Cerner might have de-emphasized interoperability to the VA to make its product seem like the only logical choice for connecting to the DoD, and while that’s just talk, the VA seems to be parroting that concept.


From Gert: “Re: MedKeeper. Was recently acquired, but the mystery is who bought them.” Unverified. The IV workflow technology company lists no press contacts or other ways to reach it beyond product sales or support, so I couldn’t ask.

From FormerCIO: “Re: Dirty Dirge’s data on CHI is incorrect – they have only 103 hospitals and the allocation of systems is also incorrect.” I don’t have access to the Definitive Healthcare database to which that reader referenced, so I can’t say, although he or she seemed pretty solid on the details.


From Bet on Black?: “Re: Allscripts. Paul Black claims 1 billion third-party API calls to Allscripts in 2017. Vendors such as Athenahealth, Epic, Cerner, and Meditech – what is your apples-to-apples comparison?” That’s an interesting question, although the admirable “openness” could be a measure of the business necessity of supporting a narrower product line. It also depends whether common integration – such as simply displaying another company’s external clinical reference information via an Infobutton – should be counted vs. sharing data with actual transaction systems. Or for that matter, if transaction count in general is more a function of client volume than technical capability. Putting out a press release invites competitive comparisons. UPDATE: Epic says they’re handling 900 million transactions per month via public APIs, 415 million per month to power customer-developed services, and 21 billion connections to/from Epic-provided services (such as mobile apps and MyChart). So we have Allscripts at 83 million transactions per month to external systems and Epic at 1.3 billion – Cerner, Meditech, and Athenahealth, you’re up, at least if you believe that interoperability is about competing vendors rather than simply being happy that the market has demanded and received API access to EHRs.

HIStalk Announcements and Requests


Welcome to new HIStalk Gold Sponsor Formativ Health. The company’s technology-agnostic patient access, revenue cycle, and practice operations services help patients feel like people and helps providers streamline operations, reduce leakage, improve insurance verification, and empower physicians to focus on keeping patients healthy. The 10-state, 450-employee company, based in New York City and a spinoff of Northwell Health, serves 3.5 million patients. It was selected a couple of months ago to provide management services to independent physicians via the Pennsylvania Medical Society’s Care-Centered Collaborative. Thanks to Formativ Health for supporting HIStalk.

This week on HIStalk Practice: 21st Century Oncology again finds itself in hot legal waters. HHS announces opioid code-a-thon winners. Clinicient acquires Keet. Infinity Behavioral Health Services acquires Health Assets Management. Greenway announces Georgia closures, layoffs. Alivio Medical Center joinsVillageMD. The FTC warns privacy-conscious consumers about at-home DNA testing kits. PRM Pro Jim Higgins shares five technological advances improving primary care communication.


I sometimes cringe upon reading negative comments left on my annual Reader Survey, no different than a mother being told by a stranger that her child is ugly. Still, I take some comfort in the many positive observations and the fact that even critics are apparently still reading HIStalk despite the flaws they perceive. I spend many hours each day writing it and ask only that you spend maybe three minutes completing the once-yearly, one-page survey to provide hopefully constructive input. You get the pride of participating in the democratic process, the satisfaction that you didn’t have to wait in a freezing voting line, the freedom from being harassed at the polls, and the hope of winning a $50 Amazon gift certificate. I’m secretly hoping that the Russians try to rig the vote.


None scheduled soon. Previous webinars are on our YouTube channel. Contact Lorre for information.

Acquisitions, Funding, Business, and Stock


The struggling Lifespan (RI) and the struggling GE (in the form of GE Healthcare) will collaborate in trying to save the health system $182 million over six years by identifying inefficiency using “cutting-edge analytics and tools.” Recently tanking GE shares are trading at their 1997 prices after a couple of bursts of misplaced investor enthusiasm, the Dow’s biggest loser since 2001 when Jeff Immelt took charge.


One-time high-flyer Greenway Health will close its Atlanta and Carrollton, GA offices in January and lay off 120 employees there as it moves operations to its Tampa, FL location. Greenway announced in October that it would merge functionality from all of its EHR/PM products into a next-generation product, but also said at that time that it would leave customer support intact in Carrollton while moving some functions to Tampa. The company was ironically recently named as Atlanta’s “Top Workplaces 2017” by the Atlanta newspaper. Greenway Health was created in 2013 as a repackaging of three holdings of its new private equity owner – publicly traded Greenway Medical Technologies, Vitera Healthcare Solutions, and SuccessEHS. Vitera was formerly Sage Software, which had purchased the former Medical Manager PM/EHR from Emdeon. Carrollton, population 25,000, is now stuck with an albatross of a street name since the soon-to-be vacated Greenway headquarters building sits on a street also named Greenway. UPDATE: the local business paper’s report that I cited was incorrect and has been updated. Greenway is moving some jobs from Carrollton to Tampa, but that office will remain open. More information is in the 12/18 Monday Morning Update.


New York EHealth Collaborative chooses Verato’s Auto-Steward for automating the correction of MPI patient mismatches on the SHIN-NY HIE.

In Canada, six-hospital CHAMP will implement Meditech’s Web EHR.



Peter Pronovost, MD, PhD — Hopkins Medicine SVP for safety and quality and perhaps healthcare’s most influential quality expert — will join insurer UnitedHealthcare as SVP of clinical strategy.

Announcements and Implementations


The HIMSS-owned Personal Connected Health Alliance releases new Continua Design Guidelines that support patients sharing data with providers.

Meditech will offer the patient electronic signatures solutions of Access in its cloud-based Web EHR subscription offering.

Government and Politics


Florida-based cancer treatment center operator 21st Century Oncology will pay $26 million to settle federal charges that submitted false Meaningful Use attestations that included falsified EHR usage data and phony utilization reports onto which it Photoshopped EHR vendor logos. The settlement also covers whistleblower-reported alleged Stark Law violations involved with paying doctors based on how many patients they referred to company-owned labs and radiation centers. 21st Century Oncology filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy earlier this year to protect itself from creditors and several fraud lawsuits.


A Chicago Tribune report finds that medical regulation is so lax in Illinois that “even the most desperate of doctors can find financial reward,” pointing out the fraud-filled home health industry that finds it easy to swindle Medicare and Medicaid. It notes that anyone can start a home health business by just paying a $25 license fee with no criminal background check required, leaving them free to troll public areas to recruit patients which, under Medicare rules, don’t have to be certified for care first.

HHS OIG approves a small pilot project in which medication management pharmacists employed by a Medicare Advantage plan will receive real-time discharge information from the hospital’s EHR to help reduce readmissions, which OIG says won’t run afoul of anti-kickback rules.


A former Johns Hopkins Health System patient appointments supervisor files a False Claims lawsuit claiming that he was ordered to “fill the plane” with patients from outside Maryland to skirt state limits on revenue paid by residents. The plaintiff says the health system’s medical concierge service prioritizes appointments for out-of-state patients as directed by top brass.

The FCC, as expected, reclassifies broadband providers as information services rather than telecommunications, reversing its 2015 ruling and freeing those companies from FCC oversight and thus allowing them to selectively prioritize or price traffic to any given website as long as they disclose their practices. Several states have already announced lawsuits challenging the decision. The broadband providers have declined to promise that they won’t do exactly what everyone fears, and unlike money-grabbing cable providers that can be easily fired, there’s no much of a cord-cutting option for the Internet unless you count cellular data. The only tiny consolation is that they didn’t abuse their customers too much before 2015, but that was a long time ago in Internet years.



Eighty percent of the 500 C-level health IT executives surveyed by Healthcare Growth Partners report no impact on their business from the Trump administration’s activities and potential ACA changes, although the report notes that provider IT capital budgets were already in place for 2017 by Election Day. The number of executives who believe health IT is in an investment bubble increased from to 36 percent from 29 percent on 2015.

In Scotland, outpatients at Glasgow hospitals miss 12 percent of scheduled appointments, with 20-something men being the least reliable. NHS Greater Glasgow plans to enhance its automated text and call reminder system to require patients to respond to prevent their appointment from being given to another patient.


Texas medical resident Rachel Pearson, MD/PhD pens an Onion-worthy letter to the editor of a magazine, complaining that none of her patients have worked a day in their lives, they are ungrateful, they vomit and pee on her, and they have to be bribed to be examined. It’s a tongue-in-cheek reference to the still-unfunded federal CHIP program that insures most of her pediatric patients.


A hospital in China suspends a radiologist after she is caught on video playing a phone game while performing a CT scan.

Sponsor Updates

  • AdvancedMD is named a leader in Gartner’s “FrontRunners for Mental health” quadrant.
  • Spok publishes an explainer video for its Care Connect product.
  • Medhost customer Mt. San Rafael Hospital (CO) becomes one of the country’s first to meet MU Stage 3 objectives.
  • Liaison Technologies awards its second Data-Inspired Future Scholarship to AI-focused high school senior.
  • Leidos Health publishes a white paper titled “From Good to Great: Strategic EHR Optimization Can Get You There.”
  • Clinical research network TriNetX adds Natural Language Processing to extract information from physician notes and clinical reports, link it to other EHR data, and then present the combined information to researchers who can then design studies and identify potential patient participants.
  • Logicworks launches targeted professional services portfolio for AWS.
  • PokitDok becomes the first healthcare technology company to achieve CAQH CORE Phase IV Certification.

Blog Posts


Mr. H, Lorre, Jenn, Dr. Jayne, Lt. Dan.
Get HIStalk updates. Send news or rumors.
Contact us.


HIStalk Featured Sponsors


Currently there are "11 comments" on this Article:

  1. Re: Former CIO and Mr Histalk
    – I can only go off the data that is listed in Definitive, which has proven to be a relatively reliable Healthcare Database as they get their data from multiple sources including CMS and HIMSS. Per their data, they list 153 Hospitals under CHI control (owned, partner, managed) Those 153 Hospitals are broken up under 15 different smaller systems/networks like Franciscan Health, KentuckyOne, Centura, St. Lukes, Mercy Health Network, etc.

    I drilled down to see what the EHR Technology was for each of the 15 smaller systems/networks but only at the corporate level and then extrapolated the data out. Unfortunately, I do not have the time to drill down into each individual hospital to look at their EHR. So, for example, KentuckyOne lists Cerner Millennium as it’s EHR at the corporate level, then I assumed Cerner Millennium for all the hospitals in that network.

    It is not my intent to ever promote false data, therefore, I have to rely on the data from what i would consider a trusted resource such as Definitive.

    • Those CHI numbers – as corrected – look more in line with the current environment. The challenge for them will be:

      1. finding the sweet spot in the value proposition to operationally support this level of EHR heterogeneity in the short term in an organization that has weathered a challenging financial turnaround in its pre-merger state

      2. Both organizations are either nearing or at the end of individual EHR plans that began maybe 5-7 years ago. They should now have a lot of experience in how those various systems have performed with respect to patient and provider satisfaction, operating resource needs and overhead requirements – as well as technical stability.

      It will be interesting to see how this all goes.

  2. Although I respect those involved, and standards work is not very glamorous, I’d really like to see a working implementation of the Continua Design Guidelines, especially one that could justify the claim on their website: “Reduced labor costs, resources and time-to-market for developer”. Looking at their certified product showcase, only 6 items have been certified in the last 2 yrs, 78/115 are “end products” like blood pressure cuffs that only need to connect via Bluetooth to meet the standard (and most do that), and out of the “personal health gateways” that submit data from the end users only two are from names doing a lot in this space – Samsung and Qualcomm. There are some other big ones on that list (Intel, IBM, Sharp, Fujitsu), but I haven’t heard anything about their products in a long time (most were certified 2014 or before).

    The technical architecture is undoubtedly part of the problem. Personal health gateways, which your cellular phone/app could be, need to submit using SOAP, FHIR, or hData (an HL7 framework), with an HL7 2.6 data payload to submit to a “health and fitness service”, presumably something like Validic or Qualcomm. What app would do that? Likewise, those health and fitness services then have to send data into an EHR using CDAs (and a bunch of other standards). Notably, only 5 products are in this category, and 4/5 were South Korean (the other Brazil). Certainly not an easy technical implementation for anyone in the consumer wearable space, and even a company dedicated to competing in healthcare would need to throw a lot of knowledgeable resources at this to just figure it out.

    It seems like the market has moved on from this.

  3. Cerner is protesting their customer’s selection of Epic? UI has experience with both Epic and Cerner and they made their choice. Why doesn’t Cerner accept that a customer has the right to decide what vendor they want?

    • My thoughts based on previous interactions with UIC and their vendor selection partner, Impact Advisors:

      – Cerner has been their EHR for almost 20 years. They were an early adopter, however, they have always been on On-Prem installation and IMO their On-Prem abilities are severely lacking. They have routine downtime’s and frankly rarely take responsibility for them, it is always someone else’s fault. This is part of the reason that in the RFP, Remote Hosting Services were included.

      – Impact Advisers – lets be honest here, while they can claim that technically they do support all EHR’s, most in the industry know that they pick Epic at an absurdly high rate when doing a vendor selection. Those in the know, know that if you want Epic as your EHR and you are doing a vendor selection, pick Impact Advisers (Mr. Histalk, I fully understand if you feel the need to remove this comment since it could be taken as vendor bashing)

      – The main issue that Cerner has (and I am surprised that Allscripts isn’t protesting as well as they finished 3rd) is that the state of Illinois has a very strict procurement process and based on the RFP (which you can find on the state procurement website) states that the final bids have to be all inclusive. Cerner’s bid was all inclusive (licensing, implementation/consulting, 3rd party integrations, etc) where as the Epic bid was only licensing. Based on State rules, this violates the RFP and, based on how the RFP was scored, severely impacted the RFP scoring.

      – when you think about it, when you include the proposed implementation services that are needed for Epic, the cost is close to double what Cerner was. When you also take into account the severe financial issues that the State of Illinois is going through, how can they justifiably spend potentially $130M….

      – This is going to get very ugly because i believe there are going to be some “skeleton’s” in the closet that are going to come out and it won’t be pretty

      – last thought, shame on Definitive Healthcare for already updating UIC’s EHR to Epic in their system….Please wait for signed contracts and implementations before updating your system..

Founding Sponsors


Platinum Sponsors

























































Gold Sponsors












Reader Comments

  • HIT Girl: My recollection from my EHR- and patient-portal building days is that restrictions vary by state, with some of the state...
  • IANAL: This company will face competition from Australians doing Outback Healthcare....
  • Mr. HIStalk: The official exhibitor count -- which includes those who just booked meeting rooms and aren't really "exhibiting" -- is ...
  • Socal: I’m pretty sure that Nuance pulled out as well as I had an email from them yesterday. I know last year there were list...
  • HIMSS No More: @Andy, Salesforce is out...

Sponsor Quick Links